Why the check happens before signing, not after
Ukrainians looking for a home in Italy usually start with photos, price and neighbourhood. Documents come last — often only when the seller is already pushing for the caparra and the agent mentions that "two other buyers" are interested. That is the moment a decision gets made that is hard to undo without a loss. Ownership, debts and legality are checked at different offices — the Agenzia delle Entrate, the catasto, the comune, the condominium administrator — and none gives a single "all clear" answer to one request.
The notary checks ownership before the deed, but does not check the state of the condominium and does not assess whether a particular preliminare's terms favour the buyer. That responsibility sits with the buyer, which is why a pre-contract check is a separate step, not a formality.
Typical consequences of a skipped check:
- An unclosed ipoteca of the seller, or a pignoramento tied to someone else's debt, remains registered on the property — found only after the deposit is paid.
- The building has an unauthorised layout change, which then makes a bank refuse the mortgage.
- The condominium approved a major renovation before signing — and the cost falls on the new owner.
- The deposit is paid against a weak preliminare that does not protect the buyer if the deal collapses through no fault of their own.
Each scenario is foreseeable and checkable before signing. Below is what gets checked, and why it matters.
Ownership: visura catastale and visura ipotecaria
The first block answers one question: can the seller actually sell what is shown in the listing, and is the property free of debts belonging to someone else?
Visura catastale and visura ipotecaria
The visura catastale is a cadastral extract: category, surface, floor, the layout on file. If the apartment has a partition wall, a balcony or a room absent from the plan, that signals an unregistered structural change. The visura ipotecaria, from the Agenzia delle Entrate, shows everything registered against the property: mortgages, pignoramenti, court-ordered restrictions and other formalità pregiudizievoli. If a previous owner's ipoteca was never closed, the buyer risks acquiring a property still securing someone else's debt.
Atto di provenienza and condominium debts
The atto di provenienza shows how the seller obtained the property — by purchase, inheritance or gift. An inheritance with minor heirs, or one where other heirs never formally renounced their share, as well as a gift, raises the risk of a later third-party challenge. Buyers should separately request a statement from the condominium administrator (certificazione dei debiti condominiali): under Italian law, a new owner is jointly liable for unpaid contributions from the current and previous year, even if the debt was run up by the seller.
Lawyer's note. The visura ipotecaria and visura catastale are official documents with a date of validity; order them directly before signing, rather than relying on a copy shown months earlier.
Legal soundness of the building: permits, sanatorie, agibilità
The second block answers a different question: was the property itself built and registered lawfully? In Italy this is exactly where the trap for a foreign buyer most often hides — the problem is not visible on a viewing, and the seller is not always aware of it either.
Conformità urbanistica e catastale and building permits
Conformità urbanistica e catastale is the match between the property's actual state and what is permitted and recorded in the cadastre; the seller declares it in the deed, and the notary requires confirmation. Every building has an original permit — a modern permesso di costruire or, for older buildings, a historical licenza edilizia — and every later layout change needs its own permit or a sanatoria, legalising works already carried out. In many older buildings some discrepancies were closed through state condoni edilizi, but their terms differ case by case and do not automatically legalise this specific apartment — that is checked on paper.
Abuso edilizio, agibilità and APE
Abuso edilizio is unauthorised work carried out without a permit and not covered by any sanatoria. It is the most serious risk in the check: such a property is practically impossible to sell lawfully, and a bank will refuse a mortgage since it cannot register a lien against an undefined legal status. The certificato di agibilità confirms the premises are fit for habitation under health rules; the APE is the mandatory energy certificate the seller must provide already at the listing stage.
Lawyer's note. A mismatch between the cadastral plan and the actual layout is one of the most common reasons a notary halts a deal at the last moment — worth catching during the check, not after the deposit is paid.
Boundaries, easements and the condominium
The third block is not paperwork on the apartment but everything around it: physical boundaries, third-party rights and the decisions of the community of owners.
Boundaries, easements and the regulation
For a house with a garden or terrace, it matters to match the actual boundaries against the cadastral plan and check whether a servitù is registered — an easement in favour of a neighbour or a utility (right of passage, pipework, a building restriction). An easement stays attached to the property and passes to the new owner with the title. The regolamento condominiale — the condominium's internal rules — governs the use of shared parts and sometimes restricts short-term rentals, which matters for anyone planning to let the property to tourists.
Verbali assemblee and already approved works
The minutes of recent owners' meetings (verbali di assemblea) show which works have already been approved, even if not yet started. As a general rule, costs approved before the ownership transfer fall on whoever owned the property at the time of the decision — but the exact wording and the date the budget was approved are decisive, which is why the minutes need to be read, not summarised secondhand by the seller.
- Requesting the last 2–3 sets of condominium meeting minutes is a standard part of the pre-signing check.
- A statement from the administrator on payments confirms there are no debts as of the request date.
- If the building is preparing a major façade or roof renovation, the cost split is worth clarifying before signing, not after.
The contract: what the preliminare must contain
The contratto preliminare di vendita (also called the compromesso) is not a formality before the "real" contract but a standalone, legally binding document. It fixes the terms that later carry over into the notarial deed, and determines how protected the buyer actually is between paying the deposit and the date of the deed.
Mandatory elements
- Precise identification of the property — cadastral data, plan, boundaries, appurtenances (cellar, parking space).
- Price, payment schedule and a clear definition of the deposit's amount and legal nature.
- A seller statement that there are no ipoteche, pignoramenti or other encumbrances — or the procedure and deadline for removing them before the deed.
- A statement on conformità urbanistica e catastale and the existence of all permits.
- The date and place of the notarial deed and the conditions under which either party may withdraw.
Conditions that protect the buyer
A well-drafted preliminare includes suspensive conditions (condizioni sospensive): for example, the deal is valid only if the buyer obtains mortgage financing on the stated terms, or only if no new encumbrances appear before the deed. Without such conditions, a buyer whose bank refuses the mortgage after signing risks losing the deposit though the refusal was not their fault. When the seller is a construction company, consumer-protection law requires the developer to provide a bank or insurance fideiussione guaranteeing repayment of sums already paid if the developer fails to complete the building or goes bankrupt. Its absence is, on its own, a reason not to sign as offered.
Lawyer's note. One well-drafted suspensive-condition clause often matters more than the rest of the preliminare combined — it determines whether the seller returns the deposit if something goes wrong outside the buyer's control.
The deposit: why not to pay caparra against a weak contract
Italian practice recognises several types of deposit, and the difference between them determines how much the buyer stands to lose if the deal falls through. The caparra confirmatoria is standard: if the buyer walks away, the seller keeps the deposit; if the seller walks away, they return double the amount. The caparra penitenziale works differently — it lets either party withdraw by forfeiting only that sum, without the right to demand performance in court. Sellers sometimes word the clause so loosely it is unclear which regime applies — directly affecting whether the buyer can demand a refund or force performance through the courts.
Paying a deposit is, on its own, a normal part of a deal. The problem arises when money changes hands before the title and legality are checked, or when the preliminare has no suspensive conditions and no clear seller statements: the buyer pays in advance for a property whose status is not yet confirmed, and if a problem surfaces after payment, getting the money back becomes a dispute, not an automatic procedure. The deposit should be paid after signing, not before, and by a method that proves the date — a bank transfer, not cash.
Lawyer's note. No sum should change hands before the preliminare is signed with its suspensive conditions in place — and never before the title and legal status are checked.
Property due diligence from Dorosh & Partners
Everything above is not a list of "just in case" tips, but a set of actions the Dorosh & Partners team carries out as a standalone service before a client signs anything or hands over any sum. The goal is a clear answer to one question: is it safe to sign this specific preliminare on these terms, and if not — what needs fixing first.
The check has several parts, each matching a section of this article:
- Title check. Ordering and reviewing an up-to-date visura catastale and visura ipotecaria, examining the seller's atto di provenienza, searching for registered mortgages and seizures, and requesting a statement on condominium debts.
- Building-legality check. Matching the cadastral plan against the actual layout, searching for construction and remodelling permits, checking any legalisation, and flagging an unclosed abuso edilizio before it becomes the buyer's problem.
- Condominium check. Reading the latest meeting minutes, the internal regulation and the payment statement, so the buyer knows about planned costs before signing.
- Review of the preliminare. Checking the contract for seller statements, suspensive conditions, a clear definition of the deposit type and, where relevant, the developer's fideiussione — before the client signs, not after.
- Support through the notarial deed. Confirming every condition of the preliminare is actually met by the time of the deed — from removing encumbrances to collecting every required statement.
These are exactly the steps where a problem is usually caught before it is too late: an unclosed mortgage, a mismatch between the cadastral plan and reality, a poorly worded suspensive condition, a condominium debt the seller "forgot" to mention. Each costs a client money, time, or both — and each is checkable before signing, not after.
Buying property often runs alongside other legal matters — obtaining or extending residence status in Italy, where the team separately supports clients with residence permits and legalisation in Italy. If the seller is a construction or real-estate company, the counterparty is checked as a business just as carefully as the property, the way it is done for clients seeking business support in Italy. The team applies the same "check the contract first, sign second" principle to rentals, with a ready-made rental contract check, and more on tenant rights is in the article on rental contract terms in Italy. For a consultation, leave a request through the consultation form — with a description of the situation and, if available, a copy of the listing or the draft preliminare.
A check before signing costs far less than fixing a problem found after the deposit or after the deed. It is not an extra cost on top of the deal — it is what makes a deal a deal, rather than a risk that has not shown itself yet.
Frequently asked questions
Is it necessary to check the property if a real-estate agency is handling the deal?
An agency checks far from everything and does not guarantee the buyer any result. Its interest is getting the deal to signature; a legal check of the title, the building and the contract is a separate function worth commissioning regardless of whether an agency is involved.
Does the notary check everything necessary at the time of signing the deed?
The notary verifies ownership and requires a statement of urban-planning compliance. But the notary does not independently investigate the state of the condominium, the content of the meeting minutes, or whether a specific preliminare's terms favour the buyer — that responsibility belongs to the parties.
What should be done if a check after the deposit has been paid uncovers a problem?
It depends on what the preliminare provided for: if it had suspensive conditions and clear seller statements about the absence of encumbrances, a breach gives grounds to demand the deposit back without loss. If the contract did not provide for this, the situation is far more difficult — exactly why the check should be done before payment, not after.
Can an apartment with an unclosed abuso edilizio be bought if the price is lower?
Formally, a deal can be structured with a condition that the seller legalises the discrepancy before the deed, but without legal control the buyer risks being left with only an unjustifiably low price compensating for the unresolved problem — not a genuinely legalised property.
How long are a visura catastale and a visura ipotecaria valid?
These documents have no fixed validity period, but their data can change any day — a new record of a seizure or mortgage can appear as soon as the following week. That is why it makes sense to order the check as close as possible to the signing date, not relying on an extract obtained earlier, at the viewing stage.
Матеріал має інформаційний характер і не замінює юридичну консультацію.